top of page

Public/Private Partnerships Review

Jun 25
4 min read

Updated: Nov 3

Start Date: 3/4/26


Why the Office of the City Auditor (OCA) did this project

This review was undertaken to assess whether the City's processes for initiating, monitoring, and sustaining P3 agreements are sufficiently mature to support current activity and scalable to meet projected growth.


Project Scope

We reviewed a sample of ten larger P3’s for contract adequacy, procedures to support City

interest and compliance with contract terms.


Why audit this topic?

Contracts were identified as a risk in the Fiscal Year 2026 Annual Audit planning process based on input from city councilors, department head interviews, and surveys of residents, employees, and auditors.


Project Procedures

This project was co-sourced with SOAR Partners, a Tulsa-based third-party provider of internal audit and other consulting services.

  • Review whether terms are appropriate for the contract, with appropriate transition protocols/requirements.

  • Review whether there are protections regarding bankruptcy (e.g. ownership of assets, ability to assume control).

  • Review whether funding requirements (variable or fixed) are clearly stated and that there are means established to assure funds disbursed will be used for the intended City objectives.

  • Review whether City objectives are clearly stated for the use of its funds.

  • Review whether there are clear Service Level Agreements (SLA’s) that can be measured with appropriate reporting (e.g. can be supported, timely, complete).


Key Observations

There were no reportable findings.


Improvement Opportunities:

  • Consider establishing and maintaining a formal, comprehensive inventory of all P3 contracts, regardless of size.

  • Develop a standardized P3 compliance framework applicable across all departments with P3 ownership responsibilities.

  • Update Mayor's Executive Order 2005-06 to reflect the current scale and complexity of the City's P3 portfolio.

  • Establish standards for defining P3 contract objectives and KPIs that are specific, measurable, and directly attributable to the P3's actions.


Audit Objective

The Office of the City Auditor (OCA) conducted a risk-based survey of citizen priorities, from which Public/Private Partnerships (P3s) emerged as an area of significant public concern—a finding consistent with risk topics already under active monitoring by the Internal Audit team. P3s represent a growing area of municipal finance nationally, with projected sector growth of 7.5% annually (from $34.8 billion in 2024 to $61.4 billion by 2032, per Prescient & Strategic Intelligence). The recent passage of Oklahoma's BUILD Act further positions the City of Tulsa for continued P3 expansion, both through new agreements and growth within existing relationships. This review was undertaken to assess whether the City's processes for initiating, monitoring, and sustaining P3 agreements are sufficiently mature to support current activity and scalable to meet projected growth.


Observations

Within our sample of 10 contracts, we did not have any reportable observations related to noncompliance with required elements. However, as we assessed the possible risks, we did identify some suggestions that might strengthen or mature the City’s risk mitigation strategy related to P3 agreements.


Improvement Opportunities


Absence of a Comprehensive P3 Contract Inventory

OBSERVATION

No single, authoritative inventory of all City P3 contracts was identified. While larger agreements with significant economic exposure were accessible and reviewed, smaller agreements lacked centralized tracking. The contract inventory obtained from the City also contained outdated information, including at least one listed contact who is deceased and one who had retired.


RECOMMENDATION

We suggest the City consider establishing and maintaining a formal, comprehensive inventory of all P3 contracts, regardless of size. This inventory should include current contact information and be subject to a defined update process to ensure accuracy over time. Capturing all agreements, not only those with significant economic exposure, will reduce the risk of unmonitored contracts and the legal liability and reputational harm that could result.



Inconsistency in Contract Oversight Practices

OBSERVATION

Interviews with the Chief Economic Development Officer and Deputy City Administrator and Director of Parks, Culture and Recreation determined that both have developed reasonable procedures for monitoring P3 relationships within their respective departments. However, both indicated their approaches were developed over time based on individual experience rather than established City guidance.


RECOMMENDATION

The City should develop a standardized P3 compliance framework applicable across all departments with P3 ownership responsibilities. The framework should be flexible enough to accommodate differing portfolio profiles—for example, the collaborative, relationship-intensive model in Economic Development and the higher-volume, varied portfolio in Parks, Culture and Recreation.



Outdated Governing Guidance

OBSERVATION

The most substantive existing guidance identified for City P3 management is Mayor's Executive Order 2005-06. While the order contains relevant content, it is limited in scope and has not been updated to reflect the significant growth in P3 activity, in both number of agreements or total dollars, since its issuance.


RECOMMENDATION

Mayor's Executive Order 2005-06 should be updated to reflect the current scale and complexity of the City's P3 portfolio. Revised guidance should be formally communicated to all staff with P3 ownership responsibilities to ensure consistent application. Keeping governing guidance current will reduce reliance on individual judgment and strengthen institutional standards for oversight, accountability, risk management and compliance.



Objectives and Measurable Service Level Agreements

OBSERVATION

Operational objectives across reviewed P3 agreements varied in clarity and enforceability. Some contracts contained priorities too numerous to drive focused performance, others included reactive rather than actionable requirements, and at least one P3 operating under multiple governing bodies lacked a clear hierarchy of objectives or vision.


RECOMMENDATION

The City should establish standards for defining P3 contract objectives and KPIs that are specific, measurable, and directly attributable to the P3's actions. Agreements should include enforceable performance standards and clearly defined penalties for non-compliance. In cases where a P3 operates under multiple governing bodies, the agreement should expressly identify which objectives and vision take precedence. Applying these standards to future agreements, and revisiting them in renewals, will strengthen the City's ability to evaluate performance and ensure P3 partners are delivering intended community benefit.



MANAGEMENT RESPONSE

Thanks for the opportunity to respond to the P3 Review conducted by the City Auditor’s Office.


The recommendations are generally well made, and updated executive guidance, as suggested in recommendation three, will be updated in the coming months. Further, the updated guidance will incorporate elements of the other recommendations presented in the review.



DOWNLOAD PDF VERSION:


 
 
bottom of page